Skip to content

Best Eyeliners in 2023

Beauty trends may come and go, but eyeliners have remained one of the best beauty products that can transform your look in just a few strokes. With a variety of shades and finishes, including liquid, gel, and pencil options, there's something for everyone. However, finding quality eyeliners can be a challenge, as not all models are created equal. Fortunately, this article will help you navigate through the vast selection and find the best eyeliners available in stores. Keep reading to discover the top picks.

Are you in a hurry?

If you're in a hurry to shop for eyeliners, we recommend taking some time to research before making a purchase. However, if you're short on time, we've got you covered. We've done the legwork for you and compiled a list of reputable eyeliners that you can trust. Keep reading to find the perfect one for you.

Best Overall



HAUS LABORATORIES by Lady Gaga offers a liquid eyeliner with a matte black finish that delivers a flawless look. Its pen design is lightweight and easy to use, making it perfect for on-the-go touch-ups. The vegan-friendly formula is available in both black and brown shades, both of which are cruelty-free. This eyeliner is suitable for all age groups and is weightless, wear-proof, and does not flake when exposed to UV rays or water, providing long-lasting wear without smudging.

Smart Pick

Xtreme Lashes Lash Eyeliner

Xtreme Lashes Lash Eyeliner

Achieve thick and stunning lashes with the Xtreme Lashes Lash Eyeliner. With its smooth texture, this eyeliner creates full and well-defined lashes for any occasion. Its dual tip technology allows for versatility in creating dramatic looks as well. Weighing 0.64 ounces, this fragrance-free eyeliner is gentle on your skin and lashes, ensuring no irritation or harm. Attend beauty school and take your eyelash game to the next level with the Xtreme Lashes Lash Eyeliner.

Budget Pick

Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil

Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil

The Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner is a smudge-proof eye pencil that features a highly pigmented formula with 13 wearable shades to choose from. Infused with vitamin E, this eyeliner helps rejuvenate the skin and lashes while providing a long-lasting finish. Its water-resistant formula ensures your makeup stays in place throughout the day. The pencil is designed to fit comfortably in your hand, providing easy control for precise application. Each stroke dries in just 20 seconds, making it a great option for those on-the-go. Take your eye makeup game to the next level with the Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner.

Buying Guide for Eyeliners

Eyeliners are a versatile makeup tool that can highlight your eyes, complement your overall makeup look, and showcase your sense of style. With a variety of colors to choose from, you can even select an eyeliner that complements your outfit. It's a good idea to own eyeliners of different colors to add variety to your makeup routine and suit different occasions. However, it's important to note that some beauty products can cause harm, so it's essential to consider safety factors when selecting an eyeliner. Keep reading this buying guide to learn what to look for to ensure you choose a safe and effective eyeliner.

Ingredients: The ingredients of an eyeliner dictate its potency and safety. The best eyeliner should contain safe ingredients to avoid messing up your health. It would also help if you bought an eyeliner with all-organic ingredients. This way, you will enhance your beauty safely and safeguard the environment.

Color: Color is what sets eyeliners apart. When choosing the eyeliner with the right color, consider the color of your skin, your outfit, and your jewelry and accessories. The ideal eyeliner should blend with all the colors you choose to pair it with.

Strength: The strength of an eyeliner refers to how long it stays in place without fading. The best eyeliner should last until you decide to remove it. It should stand water, tears, dust, and sun rays. An eyeliner that fades off easily may force you to reapply it several times a day which is inconveniencing and tiresome.

Top 5 Eyeliners in the Market this Year

Eyeliners are a popular cosmetic that, like other makeup products such as mascaraeye shadows, and eyebrow colors, can enhance the appearance of the wearer. They offer an affordable way to highlight and draw attention to the eyes or eyebrows. In this article, we'll review some of the best eyeliners that are perfect for most women. Whether you're looking for a liquid eyeliner, a pencil eyeliner, or a gel eyeliner, we've got you covered. Keep reading to find the perfect eyeliner for you.


Say goodbye to eyeliner mishaps with HAUS LABORATORIES' highly-rated eyeliner. It's a favorite among women for its ability to blend with a variety of skin tones and deliver a flawless matte black finish.

Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying eyeliner is perfect for achieving both a standard thick cat-eye and a long, reusable wingtip sticker, making it ideal for any occasion. Its unique formula creates a flawless finish that you won't find in any other type of eyeliner. Beauty is subjective, but with Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying eyeliner, you can enhance your natural beauty and feel confident in your appearance. Say hello to beautiful, defined eyes with this amazing eyeliner.

  • The formula is long-wearing and thus lasts for long hours.
  • It is weightless and will not weigh your eyelids down.
  • The flake-proof formula does not feather, skip, tug or smudge for a neat, smooth finish.
  • It is not waterproof and is easily washed off by rainwater and tears.
Our Verdict:

Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying eyeliner is designed to enhance your natural beauty and boost your confidence as a woman. Its easy-to-use formula requires no professional skills to achieve a stylish and elegant look. Overall, it's an excellent eyeliner to invest in to enhance your beauty routine.

2. Xtreme Lashes Lash Eyeliner

Looking for a precise and long-lasting liquid liner? Look no further than the Xtreme Lashes Lash eyeliner. This easy-to-use eyeliner requires no special skills and can achieve both natural and formal looks. It's also perfect for those with eyelash extensions, featuring dual-tip technology for subtle or dramatic looks.

And at the end of the day, removing the Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying eyeliner is a breeze. With its dual-ended felt-tip, you can achieve a dense lash look without tugging or scrubbing your eyelid, and easily remove it without the need for makeup remover.

  • It contains hypoallergenic ingredients to keep your skin from allergies and irritation.
  • The fragrance-free formula makes it ideal for all users, including the picky ones.
  • It is safe on your skin since it has passed dermatologist and toxicology tests.
  • The edges fade after some time and may need reapplication.
Our Verdict:

The Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying eyeliner is expertly crafted to provide you with the denser look you desire. Its tip is designed to draw a more stylish edge, giving you a more dramatic look. This makes it a valuable purchase, giving you your money's worth.

3. Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner Long Lasting Eye Pencil

The Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner has established a strong presence in the market due to its smudge-proof and highly pigmented color. Its waterproof feature allows it to last all day without fading or smudging. Additionally, this eyeliner is formulated with vitamin E, which enables it to glide smoothly and effortlessly like a liquid.

Furthermore, the Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner is available in 13 wearable shades, giving you a wide range of options to choose from according to your preference. Its gel technology enhances its longevity, ensuring that it remains intact even with teary eyes. The eyeliner glides on smoothly without any tugging, making it easy to apply in light strokes. To use this eyeliner, you need a GlideLiner sharpener, and once applied correctly, it dries in less than 20 seconds.

The Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner enables you to accentuate your natural beauty in a simple yet modern way, providing the benefits of a liquid liner while being as easy to use as a traditional pencil.

  • It is compatible with natural eyelashes and eyelash extensions.
  • Innovative long-lasting technology eliminates tugging and smudging, providing a neat finish.
  • Vitamin E ingredient therein nourishes and moisturizes your eyelids.
  • It is too soft and smears easily thus requires frequent sharpening.
Our Verdict:

To achieve a smudgy-smoky effect with the Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner, simply apply the liner and use a brush or your finger to smudge it out. This effect adds a sultry and feminine touch to your look. If you want to create a more dramatic line, you can repeat the application process to thicken the line. Overall, the Xtreme Lashes GlideLiner is a versatile and easy-to-use eyeliner that can help you achieve a range of looks, from subtle to bold.

4. Diego Dalla Palma Eye Pencil

Users of the Diego Dalla Palma Eye Pencil attest to its ease of use, thanks to its soft and large texture. It provides precise outlines without requiring professional expertise. Its rich color pigmentation ensures it stays put throughout the day.

Application of the eye pencil requires small and fine strokes for optimal results, and it blends seamlessly with powdered eye shadows. Additionally, it is available in various colors to suit individual preferences, and it blends with skin tone to achieve a natural look.

  • It is gentle and ideal for all types of eyelids and waterline.
  • The colors are deep enough to highlight your eyes with a single stroke.
  • The formula is potent and lasts the entire day with no reapplication.
  • It is unideal for sensitive eyelids as it can cause swelling.
Our Verdict:

It's incredible how the Diego Dalla Palma Eye Pencil seamlessly blends with any kind of powdered eye shadow, whether it's the same shade or a different one, and still achieves an elegant look. This eyeliner is sure to provide you with a strong and natural eye-cut design when applied. Scar gels, hair trimmers, and shampoo and conditioner sets are other wellness accessories to buy.

5. By Terry Crayon Khol Terrybly Eyeliner

This pen-shaped eyeliner with a precision tip is the ideal choice for those seeking a high-quality and long-lasting eyeliner. Its durable formula ensures that it stays put throughout the day, giving you a polished finish that will make you stand out from the crowd. Additionally, this versatile eyeliner can also double as an eyeshadow.

The high-precision pencil allows for easy and extended use, and the hassle-free application process makes it perfect for those who are not experts in applying eyeliner. Its waterproof formula ensures that it lasts all day without the need for constant reapplication.

This eyeliner provides various intense looks, with different shades to choose from based on your preferences and the occasion. The soft and creamy texture of the eyeliner also makes it ideal as an eyeshadow.

  • It is ideal for the outdoors thanks to its waterproof finish.
  • You will use it safely on your eyelids without scratching or injuring them, thanks to its soft tip.
  • It lasts for long hours, eliminating the need to carry it with you for reapplication.
  • It is too costly and thus may be unaffordable for most interested users.
Our Verdict:

The Crayon Khol Terrybly Eyeliner boasts a smooth and highly-pigmented formula that makes application a breeze, even for those without beauty expertise. This eyeliner is versatile and can be used to add a pop of color to your look, making it a great addition to your makeup kit.

Final Thoughts

Consider the safety of the eyeliner ingredients before making a purchase. Ensure that the product is suitable for your skin type and won't cause any adverse reactions. Additionally, opt for an eyeliner that is easy to apply and has a fast-drying formula to prevent smudging, peeling, or fading. Our top picks provide these benefits, making them suitable for women of all ages and backgrounds.

Leave a Reply